by Holly
Luxuriously rich, this homemade Eggnog recipe can’t even be compared to a carton from the store.
Fresh eggs, hot milk & cream, and warm spices create a decadent holiday drink.
Homemade eggnog can be made with or without alcohol and will keep about 3 days in the fridge. Party perfect.
What is Eggnog?
Eggnog is a rich creamy spiced drink. Made with milk, heavy cream, and eggs and the texture is thicker than cream. The flavor is sweet, lightly spiced, and we often add rum, brandy, or whiskey (but this can be made without alcohol too, see notes below).
We commonly see this drink in stores (and coffee shops!) during the Christmas season served as a cocktail for its festive flavor! Eggnog can be served chilled (over ice), hot, or even in a latte!
Ingredients in Eggnog
It’s hard to believe you can make such a great homemade eggnog recipe with everyday staples and a few common spices. Here’s the lineup:
Milk and cream create the base for this recipe. Adding heavy cream makes the best eggnog as it adds richness.
Egg yolks thicken the mixture, add buttery texture and give eggnog its pale yellow color. The egg yolks are tempered (which means a hot liquid is added to raw eggs a little bit at a time) to keep the mixture smooth.
While some recipes use the whole egg, we prefer to just enjoy the buttery yolks. Egg substitute will work in this recipe.
Sugar, Spice, & Everything Nice. White sugar can be replaced with any sweetener you’d like. We love cinnamon, clove, and a splash of vanilla extract. Add in your favorite warm spices from nutmeg to star anise or even cardamom.
Add alcohol (or don’t!). Add some alcohol spirits according to your preference if you’d like. Rum is our favorite spike for eggnog, we use about 1 cup but start with half and after tasting, add more if you’d like.
Save the Egg Whites
This recipe uses only egg yolks but don’t discard the whites. They can be scrambled or added to recipes.
- Meringue Cookies or pavlova are great uses for egg whites.
- Scramble them on their own (or add them to a couple of whole eggs) for scrambled eggs.
- Mix them with cheese and veggies to make egg muffins.
- Two egg whites (or approximately 1/4 cup) can replace a whole egg in many recipes.
How to Make Homemade Eggnog
These are the basic steps for making delicious homemade eggnog. Get out your wire whisk, it’s easier than you think!
- Whisk egg yolks until pale in color and slightly foamy.
- Heat milk and spices in a large pot.
- Add a bit of the heated milk to the egg yolks to temper them (more on tempering below). This keeps the eggs from ‘scrambling’.
- Heat mixture until thickened and move to an ice bath (I do this in my kitchen sink).
- Add flavors/spirits and refrigerate overnight.
Garnish the eggnog with a small dash of nutmeg, a cinnamon stick or even a sprig of rosemary.
Be sure not to boil the egg mixture, heat until the temperature of the mixture reaches 160°F on a thermometer (or until thickened).
Why and How to Temper Eggs
Tempering eggs is a way to add eggs to a hot mixture without having them scramble or get lumpy. It keeps the mixture smooth and allows the eggs to thicken the mixture.
To temper eggs, whisk eggs until they become a pale yellow color. Add about 1/2 cup of hot liquid while whisking to slowly increase the temperature of the eggs. Now add the egg mixture back into the remaining hot mixture and cook until thickened.
The Best Rum Alternatives
Other spirits will enhance your eggnog equally well. Bourbon, brandy, or Southern Comfort are great alternatives.
Or, you could get really fancy and festive and add dollops of liquor, like Amaretto, Bailey’s Irish Cream, or nutty Frangelico. Try adding Irish Cream Liquor and making a spiked eggnog latte!
To Make This Alcohol Free Simply skip the rum or add in a bit of rum extract (1 teaspoon should do).
How to Store Homemade Eggnog
Homemade eggnog should not linger for hours at room temperature. If you’re serving it in a punchbowl, put it in an ice bath, or just return the pitcher to the fridge after an hour.
Every winter celebration will be complete when you serve eggnog. Now let’s raise a cup of eggnog, dear, for Auld Lang Syne!
Have you tried this eggnog? Leave a comment and rating below and tag us on Instagram!
Homemade Eggnog Recipe
Prep Time 5 minutes
Servings 8 servings
Ingredients
- 10 egg yolks
- 4 cups whole milk
- ¾ cup sugar
- 1 cinnamon stick
- 3 whole cloves
- 1 ½ cups heavy cream
- 1 cup dark rum * optional
- 2 teaspoons vanilla
Follow Spend with Pennies on Pinterest
Instructions
- Prepare an ice bath big enough to put the bottom of the saucepan in (I use the kitchen sink).
- Whisk egg yolks until light in color and slightly foamy.
- Combine milk, sugar, cloves and cinnamon stick in a small saucepan. Whisk over medium heat until hot but not boiling.
- Scoop about 2 cups of the hot milk mixture into the eggs a little bit at a time whisking after each addition.
- Pour the warm egg mixture into the milk and whisk over medium heat until slightly thickened, about 5 minutes.
- Remove from heat, place in ice bath and whisk 2-3 minutes.
- Stir in cream, rum and vanilla. Chill at least 24 hours.
- Serve over ice with a dash of nutmeg.
Recipe Notes
Nutrition Information
(Nutrition information provided is an estimate and will vary based on cooking methods and brands of ingredients used.)
More Delicious Holiday Drinks
-
-
- Spiked Eggnog Latte – a holiday classic
- Homemade Apple Cider – delicious spiced apple drink!
- Pumpkin Spice Latte – 1000x better made at home!
- Irish Coffee – perfect after-dinner drink
- Celebration Punch – with cranberries & apples!
-
If I wanted to use ground spices as a substitution. Any recommendations on amounts I could use.
Hi Amy, we have only made this recipe as listed but if you want to try ground spices I would start with ½ to ¾ teaspoon of ground cloves and ¼ to ½ teaspoon of ground cinnamon.
Unpopular question I’m sure, but is there any substitution for the rum? Or will it just be a thicker result? Thanks!
You can leave out the rum, the consistency should be just fine. If you’d like to add flavor without the rum you can add a little bit of rum extract or brandy extract. You can also find this info in the post.
Other spirits will enhance your eggnog equally well. Bourbon, brandy or Southern Comfort, Amaretto, Bailey’s Irish Cream or Frangelico are alternatives. To Make This Alcohol Free Simply skip the rum or add in a bit of rum extract (1 teaspoon should do).
Love it all
My husband loves eggnog and I’m going to try making it for him. As I was reading over your list of ingredients and directions I couldn’t find where or when to add the 1 1/2 cups of heavy cream. Does it go in with the milk and spices?
Apologies for the confusion Carol. It is added at the end along with the rum. Enjoy!
Is it possible to make a lactose free version of this recipe? I’m thinking of replacing oat milk for the whole milk, but i’m Not sure what to use to replace the heavy cream… any suggestions?
I haven’t tried it with lactose free but I do think it would work well. As for the heavy cream, some stores do sell lactose free cream. You could also leave it out, the mixture is nice and thick without it. Let us know how it goes!
The dishes look delicious.
Would like to try your recipes.
Thank you
I can’t wait to make this! But before I do, I need some recipes for all the egg whites!
I most often use them for breakfasts and make egg muffins which freeze and reheat well. Believe it or not, they can be cooked and chilled and then served in an egg salad (or added to salads in place of hard boiled eggs).
They can be scrambled or made into egg white omelettes and raw egg whites freeze well too!! Hope that helps!