Chocolate Poke Cake From Scratch
This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my disclosure policy.
Chocolate Poke Cake From Scratch is one of the most amazing and moist cakes you’ll ever have!
A secret ingredient brings out the chocolatey goodness in the cake while adding a rich layer of homemade pudding keeps it extra moist! It’s all topped off with a simple one minute chocolate frosting!
How to Make Chocolate Poke Cake From Scratch
Pin It
Pin now to save it for later!
Follow Spend With Pennies on Pinterest for more great tips, ideas and recipes!
This is one of the most amazing chocolate cakes of all time! My son calls this his favorite cake hands down!
Making a chocolate poke cake from scratch is easier than you think and it’s so worth the extra time!
If you love a great chocolaty flavor, I have a little secret to share with you! Adding just a little bit of coffee to the batter brings out the rich chocolate flavor (but don’t worry, you don’t taste a coffee flavor). This even works in place of water if you’re making a boxed mix!
Originally I made this cake for my son’s 18th birthday…but of course when you have a house full of teenage boys and a chocolate cake, getting photos is kind of challenging. *Sigh* … so I had to make the cake AGAIN, oh the hardships, more chocolate cake! And it was just as amazing!
The cake itself is decadent and moist with an amazing rich chocolate flavor…even without the pudding on top, it is excellent!!
The homemade pudding is super easy and quick and takes this cake to the next level! The whole thing is topped with my absolute favorite one minute easy chocolate frosting. This “poured frosting” is quick to make and requires not spreading, just pour over the cake and tilt to spread!
Items you’ll need for this recipe:
- 9 x 13 pan
- chocolate chips
- cocoa powder *
After trying this Chocolate Poke Cake From Scratch, you may never want to use a boxed recipe again!
This Chocolate Poke Cake From Scratch is one of the most amazing and moist cakes you’ll ever have! A secret ingredient brings out the chocolatey goodness in the cake while adding a rich layer of homemade pudding keeps it extra moist! It’s all topped off with a simple one minute chocolate frosting!
- 1 3/4 cups flour
- 1 3/4 cups sugar
- 3/4 cup unsweetened cocoa powder
- 2 teaspoons baking soda
- 1 teaspoon baking powder
- 2 eggs
- 1 cup brewed coffee , cooled
- 1 tablespoon lemon juice
- 1 cup milk
- 1/2 cup vegetable oil
- 1/2 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 2/3 cup sugar
- 1/3 cup unsweetened cocoa powder
- 3 tablespoons cornstarch
- pinch of salt
- 2 1/4 cups milk
- 1 tablespoon butter
- 1/3 cup milk
- 1/3 cup butter , softened
- 1 1/4 cups sugar
- 1 cup semi-sweet chocolate chips
-
Preheat oven to 350 degrees F. Grease & flour a 9x13 inch pan.
-
Combine milk & lemon juice and set aside. (The mixture will thicken slightly)
-
Combine flour, sugar, cocoa, baking soda & baking powder in a large bowl.
-
Add eggs, coffee, soured milk, oil and vanilla. Beat medium speed for 2 minutes. Pour into prepared pans. (Your batter may seem runny at this point but it will bake up beautifully.)
-
Bake 30 to 40 minutes, or until toothpick inserted into center of cake comes out clean. Be sure to check the cake at 30 minutes so it doesn't over cook.
-
In a saucepan, combine sugar, cocoa powder, cornstarch and salt, mix well. Add in cold milk, stir until combined.
-
Turn heat to medium high stirring constantly until mixture comes to a boil.
-
Allow to boil for 1 minute while stirring, remove from heat and stir in butter.
-
Allow to cool for 5 minutes stirring occasionally. Poke the cake all over with the end of a wooden spoon. Pour warm pudding over warm cake. Tap the pan allowing the pudding to seep into the cake.
-
Cover and refrigerate for 4 hours or overnight. (Frost after slightly cooled, about 30 minutes)
-
In a saucepan, combine milk, butter, & sugar over medium high heat.
-
Bring to a rolling boil and allow to boil 45 seconds.
-
Remove from heat and add chocolate chips.
-
Whisk until smooth and shiny and immediately pour over the cake. Refrigerate until set.
(Nutriton information provided is an estimate and will vary based on cooking methods and brands of ingredients used.)
More Recipes You’ll Love
Triple Chocolate Banana Bread
Cookie Sheet Chocolate Cake from Chef in Training
Chocolate Lasagna from CenterCut Cook
Cake adapted from allrecipes.com
Holly
Holly is a wine and cheese lover, recipe creator, shopping enthusiast and self appointed foodie. Her greatest passion is creating in the kitchen and making deliciously comforting recipes for the everyday home cook!
Question: Have you ever tried freezing this cake afterafter completing it? This question was not answered. Need a cake to make ahead when I don’t have access to an oven.
I have never tried freezing it. You could try making the cake, poking it, then freezing. When you need the cake, add the pudding and frosting.
I’m allergic to coffee, what substitute could I use? Thanks
You can use milk or water in place of coffee.
I want a video in order to make a perfect poke cake
I have added a video to the recipe.
This recipe is so great, so i want to do this tonight
Enjoy, Elmira!
I made this recipe for my son’s birthday and everyone loved it.
So glad that everyone enjoyed it!
Love this cake receipe, this is the second time I have made it, and my husband said it was possibly the best chocolate cake he has ever had. Made another one today for my Dad having hip replacement on Thurs. Thank you for this receipe.
So glad you and your husband enjoyed this recipe Fay!
Hi Holly I ran into your recipe as I was looking for a chocolate cake to make for my husband’s birthday. From the looks of the recipe and the comments posted the cake sounds delicious and I’m so excited to try it… one quick question.. the butter.. is it unsalted butter or regular butter? I usually use Imperial butter sticks when I bake but I want to make sure. Thanks!!
I usually use salted butter. Enjoy the cake and birthday celebration!
This is excruciatingly sweet. My family are big chocolate lovers, but this is just too much. It’s disappointing really; I was super excited to make this for my husband’s 30th birthday, and it baked well and now I know how to make pudding from scratch, so that’s awesome, but the level of sugar is just.. I mean it’s teeth-aching, taste-bud-melting, insulting-requiring sweet.
Sorry you didn’t enjoy it, we love this cake. I find it rich but not overly sweet. :)
THIS IS THE BEST CHOCOLATE CAKE EVER! And I mean it! I have been searching for a decadent moist and delicious chocolate cake for soooooo soooooo long and none of them worked, but this is HANDS DOWN THE VERY BEST CHOCOLATE CAKE EVER! Thank you for sharing such a delicious yummy and perfect recipe!
Yay Zena, so happy to hear you loved it so much!
Do you use self rising or all purpose flour?
I use all purpose flour.
super duper yummy :-) my family and friends loved it and I am selling some every now and then ;)
I am so glad that you are enjoying this recipe Jasmin!
Hi is there any way to use self rising flour ?
I’m sure that would work however I’ve only tried it as written.
I am a novice in the kitchen and I found this recipe when we were stuck inside due to bad weather and craving dessert. I substituted dark chocolate cocoa because it’s all I had on hand & for chips, I used 3/4 cup milk chocolate and 1/4 cup white chocolate for the same reason. Still turned out amazing! I shared it with my neighbors and they said it was the best chocolate cake they had ever tasted and wanted more. A big hit all the way around. Thanks!
I am so glad you were able to make this recipe work with what you had on hand!
Made this for Christmas and it was delish! I kept in the fridge so it took awhile for the frosting to “soften” so it was easier to cut. I don’t even think it needs the frosting part. I followed the recipe exactly and it turned out perfect, the pudding heavenly – will be saving that if I just want pudding! Thanks for the recipe!!
I am so glad you enjoyed this recipe!
I made this cake it was soooooo delicouse. Thank u for this wonderful recipe
I am so glad you enjoyed this recipe!
Any idea why I’m not able to see the actual recipe but can see everyone’s comments! No fair! I want to try my hand at this awesome cake!! Lol!
We apologize for any inconvenience! There was a glitch on the site which has now been fixed. Please let us know if you have any further trouble.
I have made this cake for work and home. It is loved by all. A chocoholics dream. Absolutely wonderful!
This was such an enjoyable cake to make!! Lots of steps but I loved spending the time in the kitchen. Having said that, the actual cake was disappointing Because of all the time I spent in it I expected it to be GLORIOUS and it was just okay. Not decadent, like I had expected. But maybe it’s probably me, I enjoy more of a milk chocolate or fudge flavor. My chocolate loving family felt the same way.
I was a little worried about trying a new recipe when I had to make enough for 50 people, but I read the comments, and decided to give it a try. I bake a lot, and make this quantity once a month, and this was absolutely one of the best chocolate cakes I had ever made. The recipe was easy to double, so I only had to make two batches, the instructions were very clear, the results, delicious. The only problem I had was the pudding never boiled, so it might have gotten a bit thick before pouring over the cake, but I will watch out for that next time.Leftovers stayed nice and moist in the fridge for several days.Thank you so much for a wonderful chocolate cake!
I am so glad you enjoyed this Karen! Thank you for your kind words, you really made my day!
Soured Milk??? What is that?
To sour milk you add a bit of lemon juice to milk. It is listed in step 2 of the directions. Hope that helps!
Can it be served warm after the refrigeration sets it? If so, how would you recommend?
I would serve this room temperature. If you’d like it warm you could microwave it very slightly however this would likely cause the frosting to melt.
Best cake I have ever made, and I am an avid cook. Someone else mentioned it’s a “PMS cake” ….YES! I will be making this cake once a month for life and passing it on to younger generations. It is THAT good. Satisfies every type of chocolate craving I have at once. And it’s soo easy. And I usually have all ingredients in hand. Thank you for sharing!
I am so glad you like the cake, Melissa! It is definitely the go-to cake for chocolate cravings!
The cake was really good! Everyone in the fam loved it! Thanks for this cake, cuz it’s AWESOME!!!
I am so glad your family enjoyed this recipe Faith!
Do I have to refrigerate the cake for 4 hours? I am making this cake because guests are coming and time is not with me. Can I represent the cake while it is warm?
Letting is set for 4 hours allows a chance for the pudding to soak into the cake and make it moist. It would still be good warm though! Enjoy!
Delicious but recipe calls for a TON of sugar. I used 1/2 the sugar in the cake and pudding, and no sugar in the frosting, and it still turned out decadent and sweet!
That is great to know CJ! Thanks for letting us know it was great with less sugar!
It’s a snow day! I thought I had more coffee and all I have is pumpkin flavored coffee and espresso. Do you suggest I do a long espresso and add water to make a cup or just use the pumpkin?? Thank you!
I think either would be delicious in this recipe.
One of the better chocolate cakes I have ever made. Super moist. Easier to make than I thought it would be, especially the pudding. Did not add the frosting this time. Maybe next time. Put a scoop of vanilla ice cream on the side. Extra yummy. I highly recommend this cake. 4 1/2 stars.
I love your recipes. So easy to follow and they are all good. Thank you.
Hi Holly
How can I make a vanilla moist came out of this recipe. I live chocolate but my husband love a moist vanilla cake. Would love to hear from u.
Thanks
I haven’t made this recipe as a vanilla cake.
Do you store the cake in the fridge?
You can refrigerate the cake (because of the pudding layer) but leave it out about an hour or so before serving.
I love your chocolate poke cake. It’s easy, tasty and entire,y homemade. Great job.
Instead of 1 cup coffee, could you use a cup of Coca Cola?
I haven’t tried it that way but I can’t see why it wouldn’t work.
Just finished making this cake, got it in the frig and WOW! I can’t wait to have a slice. Heading to the store for some vanilla ice for when it’s ready. I haven’t tasted the cake but did lick the spoon from the pudding and frosting, awesome! And I used all dark chocolate . Thank you for what I am sure the only chocolate cake for this house.
I hope your family enjoys it as much as we do Vicki!!
Trying this today!!!
I’d love to try this recipe, but am unsure about using cup measurements for the butter and chocolate chips in the frosting, as we would you gram measurements in the UK. Can you advise how much the weight would be in grams please?
I’m sorry, I don’t have this recipe in grams however you may be able to find a conversion chart online.
This looks really delicious – however…………I count 3 2/3 Cups of sugar – that is a TON of sugar for one cake.
This cake looks amazing! Would love to try it. Has anyone made it using gluten-free flour? If so, what kind? Thanks.
Does the cake have to stay refridgerated, after fully making it? Or can it be out?
I usually refrigerate it (because of the pudding layer) but leave it out about an hour or so before serving.
Can I substitute the lemon juice with lime juice in the cake?
The lemon juice is to sour the milk in this recipe (it doesn’t add flavor). I would suggest substituting it with white vinegar if you don’t have lemon juice or to replace the milk/lemon juice with buttermilk.
I was craving chocolate so I searched “chocolate cake” on pinterest. This was the one I had to try…and let me tell you….it is absolutely the most delicious chocolate cake in existence. Also, the way you write your recipe is so easy to follow. Thank you for this recipe!
✌️ Keli
Hi from the UK. Itching to try to make this but always get confused as to the conversion into grams and ml. Do you have a recommended link or way of working these measurements out please? Thanks in advance x
Hi Jill, I’ve found an online converter that might be able to help you!
http://www.goodtoknow.co.uk/recipes/531168/cups-to-grams-converter
I’m planning on serving this cake this Sunday around dinnertime. Would it be alright to make it on Friday or is that too long to let it hang out in the fridge? This looks amazing btw! Thanks!
This cake would be completely fine made 2 days before! I would refrigerate it and then about an hour before serving let it sit at room temp.
I was reading through all the comments and noticed you said in one response that you use Non-Rising all purpose flour. Does that just mean it’s regualr all purpose flour and NOT self rising flour?
Just regular all purpose flour.
Am I wrong I read chocolate caramel poke cake .What happened to the caramel? I have made one similar to this and spread the caramel on after it has been refrigerated over night and then put the frosting on . I this how you would do it with this particular recipe? The way I see it the more calories makes it tastier.
This cake doesn’t have caramel however I do have a caramel chocolate poke cake. https://www.spendwithpennies.com/caramel-chocolate-poke-cake/
Thank you for sharing this recipe! Do you use butter milk (is that the sour milk you use?) for all the parts that require milk or just for the cake portion? Thanks!
The soured milk is made in step #2 but you could certainly sub in buttermilk.
When go you add milk and lemon juice,it says set aside
Then no further directions are given
The soured milk is added in step 4.
How do I print the recipe without printing 40 pages of other stuff?
There is a print button to the right if the ingredients list.
I made this wonderful recipe for a picnic and it was fantastically delicious! I absolutely love the THREE layers of chocolate! The cake was moist. The pudding layer was an added bonus. The frosting supurb! This will definitely go on my fav list!
I’m so glad you loved it Lisa!
Can I reduce the sugar content? If so, by how much?
I have only made this recipe as written.
Thanks,
I tried it out and it turned out really great! I just used one cup of sugar in the cake mix, which didn’t affect the flavor!
Thanks for the great recipe!!!
So glad you enjoyed it!
I made this last week and my family love it. Can I substitute the vegetable oil with melted butter?
I haven’t tried this recipe with butter so I can’t say for sure.
If i had to remove the eggs in this recipe bcos of egg allergy would you know what i could replace it with for it to still work?
I’m sorry, I haven’t tried this without eggs but maybe somebody else will have a good suggestion.
flax eggs- I don’t remember the exact measurements offhand, but easy to look up!
I have a recipe similar to this one but I will give this one a try my chocolate
I hope you enjoy it!
I just made this and I have a question. Is the pudding suppose to cover the top after poured over? I guess I was just thinking it would somehow get sucked down into the holes. I did tap the pan several times. It just seems like a lot of pudding on top. I’m sure it will be delicious either way. I was just curious. I still need to make the frosting and pour over, but I’m excited to try it! Yesterday was my birthday and I wanted to make this, but the day got away from me so I’m doing it today. Thanks for the recipe!
Happy Birthday! I hope your day (and your cake) was wonderful! It does sit on top and create a layer. While it rests for 4 hours a lot of the pudding will seep into the cake but you will still have thin layer on top.
Hi,so do you use All-purpose flour
Yes, I use all purpose flour for this recipe.
Can you taste the coffee in the finished product?
You cannot taste the coffee in this recipe.
I made this last week, Turned out fantastic, My husband loved it!! will absolutely be making this again
I’m so glad he loved it! :)
Can this recipe be doubled?
This recipe can be doubled but would need to be baked in two 9×13 pans.
What could I use instead of Lemon Juice?
You could either use white vinegar or replace the milk & lemon juice with buttermilk.
I had to make this twice because everyone at work loved it! My boss is on a carb free diet but she had to have a second piece.Thank you for the recipe!
I’m so glad everyone loved it!
How far in advance can the cake be made? I need to bring a cake to a dinner party tomorrow evening around 6 – can I make it tonight and keep it in the fridge until I have to leave for the party? Thanks!!
Yes, this can definitely sit overnight, even a couple of days in the fridge and still be perfect!
Has anyone ever froze this cake? I am dying to try this out! Thanks
I made this poke cake with some changes. To make it more healthy i just pour chocolate frosting all over the cakewith some holes in the cake and it came out delious and not to sweet
Do i take the cake out of its mold?
No, this cake is served from the baking dish.
So after 1 week in the fridge, I finally ate the last piece of this cake. It held up well in a airtight container. I followed the directions, and cake was a bit runny when I put it in the oven. I had to bake it an extra 10-15 minutes longer than stated. Othet than that i followed the recipe exactly, quite easy to follow, and all I have to say is WOW!! This has been by far the best chocolate cake I have ever had, and I’m pretty picky. The moistness of this cake is to die for, not to mention that it is so rich! Better have your glass of milk handy…. you will definitely need it. LOVE, LOVE, LOVE this cake!
I’m so glad you loved it Vanessa! Thank you for sharing, great to know it kept a whole week in the fridge… although I’d have to hide it way in the back corner to keep it that long around here! ;)
Do you have a recipe like this, but other than chocolate? It’s my favorite, but my hubby is more vanilla, banana, coconut type.
I don’t have a poke cake that isn’t chocolate however my friend Averie has a couple of delicious recipes!
http://www.averiecooks.com/2015/06/pineapple-poke-cake-with-pineapple-glaze.html
http://www.averiecooks.com/2016/05/better-anything-peanut-butter-cake.html
My grandma used to make jello poke cakes. Use any flavor/s jello you like and make the cake the same as this recipe (any flavor cake) poke holes add liquid jello and refrigerate. So yummy!
I agree Keegan, poke cakes are so yummy and just so tasty and moist!
Este es el pastel de chocolate mas delicioso que he probado en mi vida!!!!! Me quedó PERFECTO!
Thank you Holly for this fabulous cake recipe! I needed a last minute cake for my moms birthday and this was perfect especially since I had all the ingredients. The recipe was super easy to follow…..i put it in the back in oven right before serving. It was warm and delicious and went great with ice cream. It blew everyone away at the party :) Thanks again lol!
Nicole that’s great, I’m so glad everyone loved it!! Happy Birthday to your mom!! :)
IS the soured milk butter milk?
You can use buttermilk in place of soured milk or you can make your own soured milk by adding 1 cup milk & 1 tablespoon lemon juice or vinegar and letting thicken for 5 minutes or so.
Hi holly, the amount of sugar is too large in the cake.. Can i use a lower amount? Like 3/4 cup which i think would be enough to get regular sweet taste.
If yes would i decrease any of the liquid ingrediants?
Same questions goes for the pudding.
Thank you
I have only made the cake as written and it turned out perfectly for me as well as many other readers. I can’t say for sure how it would work if you reduce the sugar.
I half the amt of sugar in EVERTHING I bake & cook, & don’t adjust anything else. So far so good…
How far are the holes supposed to go down?
I do them almost all of the way.
Ok thanks. I’m making it for my brother’s bday Saturday so I hope it turns out ok.
You’re welcome! Happy Birthday to your brother!
I’m in the middle of making this now for my husband and I’m a little worried. I didn’t notice that the “pudding” had to set! We are having a birthday celebration this evening… just wondering if it’s ok to eat before its completely set? I’m thinking it’ll get about 1.5 hours, maybe the freezer instead of fridge?
Oh yes, it should be fine in 1.5 hours. The setting just allows time for the pudding to soak into the cake making it extra moist. I would suggest just leaving it in the fridge.
Very Good, I cooked this for my Granddaughters today.
Does it matter what kind of milk you use? We drink skim milk – would a different milk taste better? I can’t wait to try this!
I usually use 2% but skim should work fine!
Why is my frosting so runny??? I did just like you said but it’s awfully runny. I do use almond milk does this change it??
Yes, it’s likely that because you changed the ingredients this changed the consistency of your frosting.
Ingredients list says milk… The directions say soured milk… What does this mean and how does one turn regular milk into soured know quickly? Sorry new at this baking thing:-)
In step #2 you combine the milk with lemon juice which causes it to sour. This would be the soured milk you will add.
STILL A LITTLE CONFUSED….. DO YOU POUR FROSTING ON BEFORE OR AFTER YOU REFRIGERATE CAKE OVERNIGHT?
Allow the cake to cool about 30 minutes and then frost it. Once frosted you can refrigerate overnight.
Trying with cupcakes tonight. Hope it turns out!
I’ve love to hear how it works for you!!
I really hate coffee, does this have a strong coffee flavor. If so can I substitute the coffee for something else, that will still give the same result
It doesn’t have a strong coffee flavor but you can certainly substitute it for water.
Thank you, will try it tomorrow
This cake is famous around my household. They’re known to eat 4-5 pieces in one sitting. It’s kind of gross to watch. But seriously, this cake is amazing.
LOL! I’m so glad your family loves it Carleen!
This is very yummy! I am always afraid of making recipes I see on pinterest because I have been so excited about a recipe then it turns out tasting aweful. I try and read comments before making something but some times all there are are a bunch of comments saying it LOOKS good nothing stating that they tried it and it was good. This said lol it is a very good recipe. I did however have to change a couple of things with the pudding. I did not have corn starch so I used flour so if anyone runs in to tha problem they can use 1tbl of cornstarch=3 tbl of flour. And I ran out of cocoa so had to use part cocoa and part chocolate cooking bar. It probably would have been better if I was able to follow the recipe exactly but it still turned out great! Also, I did not let it sit for 4 hours. For one, I don’t like cold cake and for two I am not that patient lol. I ate a piece after about a hour of it being in the fridge so it was still a little warm and gooey. Thank you for the recipe
I just made this today and i made it in 3 round pan…baked 20 min …i actually stacked it in a trifle dish…filled it to the top and will be taking it to a party tomm evening…It looks pretty impressive… I will have to cut and scoop out of the dish but I am use to serving trifle so should be fine!! I am excited to taste and I think it would be great with vanilla ice-cream. Thank- you.
I recommend removing all the icons from the left side of the screen, as it makes it hard to see the article and recipe… just a suggestion!
Thank you for letting me know Sharon! I had some recent site updates and just learned of this problem. I have someone looking at it today.
Quick question: is the frosting supposed to harde or become the consistency of a can of frosting? Mine got hard right away. Just curious! Thanks!
Mine usually hardens slightly. The frosting is definitely not as soft as canned frosting.
I made this today for my husbands birthday. Really yummy. I halved the cake recipe and used a 9 inch round pan-it baked in 25 minutes. I made the full amount of pudding because my husband is a big pudding fan (freak). Loved it. Thanks for a great recipe.
Do we put the pudding and frosting together?
The frosting goes on after the pudding layer has cooled.
I made this cake last night and I can’t wait to try it tonight. Should It be stored in the Fridge even after it sets?
I store it in the fridge because of the pudding. I prefer to take it out an hour or two before serving.
Just made a “3” hole chocolate cake! Easy and delish! The recipe sounds good – I would cut out some sugar!!!!
How many does this serve?
This makes a standard 9×13 pan. I usually cut it into 15 pieces.
Can I substitute equivalent amount of buttermilk for the lemon juice and milk?
Yes, that would work perfectly.
Does the pudding soak into the cake? I don’t like the texture of pudding but it might be ok if it soaks into the cake. Any feedback n this?
If I’m out of corn starch can I use regular Jello Pudding? I’d love to try this out tonight!
I have only tried the recipe as written but I have seen other recipes using Jell-o Pudding. If it is the cooked pudding that should work well.
A lot of first time cooks, i see.
Good morning! Do you think I’d be able to use two 9″ pans with this recipe? I am eager to try it out, but I prefer double layered cakes instead of pan cake. My only concern is that the batter will not set correctly if I layer them.
Thank you,
Meaghan
I have only made this recipe in a 9×13 pan so I can’t say for sure. The cake is very moist.
This is incredible. I’m sharing it and making it and really going to like eating it! Thanks for the post! #ilovechocolate
Tried it yesterday. Turned out great.
Thanks!
I just made this. HOLY CHOCOLATE GOODNESS! I did every step as you have in the recipe. It turned out better than any cake I’ve ever made. To those that it didn’t turn out, I’m truly sorry. This is the best PMS cake, ever. I can’t wait to add some Vanilla ice cream to this!
Can I use a cup of hot chocolate (cold , of course) or chocolate milk in place of coffee?
I think that would work just fine Judy.
can i leave out the pudding layer if i really cannot stand pudding? will it still be cake with yummy frosting?
Yes, the cake will still be moist & delicious!
If you don’t like pudding, there are lots of other things you can pour over a poke cake including sweetened condensed milk (my favorite) or ice cream topping as well.
Would you pour one or two cans (the smallish cans) of sweetened condensed milk? I’m thinking two because when I have done a poke cake half the size I used one, BUT it was also a very dense cake.
I guess I can bake it and see how things look, but any input would be appreciated :-)
Great question. I often do a 9×13 cake with 1 can of sweetened condensed milk and one small can of caramel ice cream topping and it’s amazing. I would start with one can, you want to make sure there’s enough to seep into the holes and soak into the cake and add a second can if you think you need more to soak in.
What kind of coffee did you use?
I just used my Starbucks dark roast but any kind of brewed coffee will work perfectly!
I tried to make this today but the batter turned our so runny that I thought that there would be no chance of it turning out all right and I threw it away. I was so sure i got the ingredients right. Now I’m annoyed because I should have tried it!!!
Yes, that is supposed to be the consistency of the batter but it does bake up perfectly moist and delicious.
I made this cake today, and the end result was delicious!
However, I did not think the cake would come out properly until after I took the first bite. The cake batter was incredibly runny, so much so that I questioned whether it would become cake at all. I had to leave the cake in the oven much longer than planned in order for the center to cook. I made the requisite holes for the pudding, but it seemed like more of the pudding went over the sides of the pan than in any of the holes I made. By the time I had poured frosting onto the cake, my 9X13 was so full that one wrong move on the way to the fridge would have sent a searing waterfall of chocolate pain over my hands.
Thank you so much for this comment, I am in the middle of making this cake with my kids now, and I was worried I had missed something as the “batter” (I don’t think I could even call it that!) is so runny, but I’m glad to know that it turns out well in the end.
Thanks again :)
Can I add m&ms on chocolate frosting to decorate the cake for kids’ birthday?
That would be great! The frosting sets fairly quicky so you’d have to sprinkle them right away to make them stick.
If you really hate coffee . can you just add more milk?
Yes, or you could substitute water as well.
The sugar that you used in frosting and pudding is it the confectioners sugar or the regular sugar?
I used regular sugar in both.
The pudding step:
Do I “cool completely” or cool for 5 minutes?
The frosting: is it frost 30 minutes after the pudding goes in or after the 4 hours or overnight refrigeration (which would make it a cold cake).
If you mean frost after 30 minutes, then please move the refrigerate 4 hours or overnight after frosting instructions, not after the pudding instructions.
I have tried the pudding both ways and it worked best if it was still warm when poured over the cake.
The frosting is separate from the refrigeration as not everyone will choose to add the frosting portion.
I still don’t understand Holly. I want to add the pudding layer AND the frosting. Do I add the frosting 30 mins after the pudding layer is added to the cake OR after the refrigeration of the cake for 4 hours/overnight?
Yes, you would add both, you just need the pudding layer to cool before adding the frosting.
Bake the cake and while the cake is warm, add the pudding layer. Once you have added the pudding you can refrigerate the cake and let the pudding cool for 30 minutes.
Once the pudding has cooled 30 minutes, you can add the frosting and continue to refrigerate 4 hours or overnight.
The whole family loved it ❤ Thanks for the amazing recipe
I’m so glad you loved it!! :)
Best cake I have ever made! Already have request for it for family gathering! Thanks.
You’ve listed cocoa and cocoa powder. Are they the same thing ?
Yes they are Jeanne.
when you say cake / pudding/ frosting sugar which type are you using? And is the flour you use a non rising flour is that why you use the baking powder and soda?
The sugar is regular granulated sugar and the flour is non rising all purpose flour.